Tree Protection and Construction Concerns in Durango's City Hall Project
After establishing several tree protection zones for the city of Durango’s new city hall project, construction crews dug a trench that exposed the roots of the renowned “Sir Douglas Fir – the Learning Tree”, a century-old Douglas fir situated in front of the Community Development and Engineering building.
During the Tree of the Year competition, the fir was celebrated for its resilience amidst urban development. A sign, which included a QR code for voting, stated that the tree would be preserved during construction. However, on Nov. 12, a resident noticed a trench within the tree protection zone, revealing its roots.
The trench was positioned approximately 19 feet from the tree’s trunk, as reported by Ben Rieck, the city arborist. According to the landscaping plan, a maximum of two roots, each 3 inches in diameter, can be removed. Yet, Rieck observed ten roots of this size or larger that were damaged, with some requiring city approval for removal.
The damaged roots exhibited signs of mechanical excavation, characterized by torn, crushed, and splintered wood fibers. While the report focused on documenting the damage, Parks and Recreation Director Scott McClain acknowledged the potential long-term effects on the tree’s health.
Arborist oversight is mandatory for construction within tree protection zones, a protocol not followed by the general contractor FCI, as noted in Rieck’s report. Construction management services are provided by The Artaic Group.
Tree protection on city projects demands coordination across multiple departments, including Parks and Recreation, Public Works, and Community Development. Following the incident, Community Development Director Jayme Lopko emailed The Artaic Group, emphasizing the importance of adhering to established tree protection zones.
Moving forward, the city intends to enhance communication with its construction partners to ensure proper oversight and protection. However, the trench and its impact on the tree have left a negative impression among some residents, casting doubts on the city hall project’s progress.
“The city hall/police facility project is off to a very bumpy start,” stated Peter Schertz, the resident who reported the trench. “It does not instill confidence in the city’s management capabilities or the chosen general contractor.”
Holly Jobson, who nominated the tree for Tree of the Year, expressed similar concerns about the tree’s future, given the construction-related damage.