Summary Judgment Without Claim Construction - Patently-O

Summary Judgment Without Claim Construction - Patently-O

Edge Systems LLC v. Cartessa Aesthetics, LLC (Fed. Cir. 2026) (non-precedential)

By Dennis Crouch

Edge Systems is the company behind the Hydrafacial, a hydradermabrasion treatment using a handpiece that combines suction and liquid serums to exfoliate and clean skin. They have approximately 36,000 consoles in spas and medical offices, with about 75% of their revenue coming from serums and tips.

Their US9550052 patent covers the console aspect of this system, claiming a "manifold" that connects multiple bottles of treatment liquid to a single handpiece line, allowing the operator to select from them. Edge sued Cartessa for patent infringement in 2020, claiming that Cartessa's Skinwave system infringes their patent.

The following image shows Edge's annotated Skinwave, highlighting the claimed manifold:

Skinwave with labeled manifold

District Judge Gary Brown (E.D.N.Y.) granted summary judgment of non-infringement without construing the term manifold. He concluded that Edge couldn't prove infringement because its expert had never even opened the device.

On appeal, the Federal Circuit:

  • Vacated the lower court's decision, stating that the construction of the term manifold must come first, as a reasonable jury could find the device meets Edge's proposed construction.
  • Affirmed the summary judgment of non-invalidity.

It seems some lower courts have become too quick to decide patent cases independently, without fully trusting the jury system.

To continue reading, become a Patently-O member. Already a member? Log in for full access.

Leave a Reply